Spa Relax Hotels Shelter Island
Shelter Island
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0

Child’s age:

Shelter Island

Oct 19 - Oct 20 ·
2 guests

Luxury Hotels in Shelter Island

Shelter Island
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0

Child’s age:

Navigation

1. The Pridwin Hotel

2. Sunset Beach

3. Hilton Mystic

4. Omni New Haven Hotel At Yale

5-Star luxury hotels in Shelter Island

5. Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg

6. Saybrook Point Resort & Marina

7. The Study At Yale

8. Marina Bay Cottages

9. The Hotel Maria

10. The Shoals Suites & Slips

Top luxury hotels in Shelter Island

  • Private beach
The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel

The Pridwin Hotel

81 Shore Road
3.1 km (1.9 mi) from city center
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Steam room
  • Pool with view
8.5
61 reviews
~ US$334 / night

The Pridwin Hotel

3.1 km (1.9 mi) from city center
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Steam room
  • Pool with view

The Pridwin Hotel

8.5
61 reviews
From US$ 334 / night
  • Top location
Sunset Beach Sunset Beach

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Road
2.3 km (1.5 mi) from city center
  • Restaurant
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Luggage storage
  • Golf centre
8.2
8 reviews
~ US$596 / night

Sunset Beach

2.3 km (1.5 mi) from city center
  • Restaurant
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Luggage storage
  • Golf centre

Sunset Beach

8.2
8 reviews
From US$ 596 / night

Luxury hotels near Shelter Island

  • Guest favorite
Hilton Mystic Hilton Mystic

Hilton Mystic

20 Coogan Boulevard
46.6 km (29.0 mi) from Shelter Island
  • In-room breakfast
  • Car park
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Live entertainment
  • Heated swimming pool
8.5
622 reviews
~ US$119 / night

Hilton Mystic

46.6 km (29.0 mi) from Shelter Island
  • In-room breakfast
  • Car park
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Live entertainment
  • Heated swimming pool

Hilton Mystic

8.5
622 reviews
From US$ 119 / night

5-Star luxury hotels in Shelter Island

  • Great deal
Omni New Haven Hotel At Yale Omni New Haven Hotel At Yale

Omni New Haven Hotel At Yale

155 Temple Street
55.9 km (34.7 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Valet parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Sauna
8.1
587 reviews
~ US$73 / night

Omni New Haven Hotel At Yale

55.9 km (34.7 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Valet parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Sauna

Omni New Haven Hotel At Yale

8.1
587 reviews
From US$ 73 / night
Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg

Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg

1830 West Main St (Rt 25)
36.1 km (22.4 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Live entertainment
  • Outdoor swimming pool
9.1
139 reviews
~ US$173 / night

Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg

36.1 km (22.4 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Live entertainment
  • Outdoor swimming pool

Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg

9.1
139 reviews
From US$ 173 / night
  • Best-rated
  • Beach access
Saybrook Point Resort & Marina Saybrook Point Resort & Marina

Saybrook Point Resort & Marina

Two Bridge Street
24.0 km (14.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • In-room breakfast
  • Valet parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Steam room
  • Indoor swimming pool
9.2
275 reviews
~ US$294 / night

Saybrook Point Resort & Marina

24.0 km (14.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • In-room breakfast
  • Valet parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Steam room
  • Indoor swimming pool

Saybrook Point Resort & Marina

9.2
275 reviews
From US$ 294 / night
The Study At Yale The Study At Yale

The Study At Yale

1157 Chapel Street
56.5 km (35.1 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Valet parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Fitness centre
8.7
595 reviews
~ US$209 / night

The Study At Yale

56.5 km (35.1 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Valet parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Fitness centre

The Study At Yale

8.7
595 reviews
From US$ 209 / night
Marina Bay Cottages Marina Bay Cottages

Marina Bay Cottages

334 Rope Ferry Road
32.0 km (19.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Billiard tables
  • Garden area
8.6
207 reviews
~ US$161 / night

Marina Bay Cottages

32.0 km (19.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Billiard tables
  • Garden area

Marina Bay Cottages

8.6
207 reviews
From US$ 161 / night
  • Private beach
The Hotel Maria The Hotel Maria

The Hotel Maria

132 Atlantic Avenue
52.4 km (32.5 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
  • Valet parking
  • 24-hour security
  • Air conditioning
  • Golf centre
  • Sun terrace
9.3
86 reviews
~ US$225 / night

The Hotel Maria

52.4 km (32.5 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
  • Valet parking
  • 24-hour security
  • Air conditioning
  • Golf centre
  • Sun terrace

The Hotel Maria

9.3
86 reviews
From US$ 225 / night
The Shoals Suites & Slips The Shoals Suites & Slips

The Shoals Suites & Slips

61600 Main Road
5.5 km (3.4 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Picnic area/ Tables
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour security
  • Air conditioning
  • Bar/ Lounge area
  • Sun terrace
9.6
38 reviews
~ US$199 / night

The Shoals Suites & Slips

5.5 km (3.4 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Picnic area/ Tables
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour security
  • Air conditioning
  • Bar/ Lounge area
  • Sun terrace

The Shoals Suites & Slips

9.6
38 reviews
From US$ 199 / night
  • Beach access
Quality Suites Stratford Quality Suites Stratford

Quality Suites Stratford

1500 South Avenue
68.2 km (42.4 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Laundry
  • Ironing facilities
  • Fitness centre
7.5
562 reviews
~ US$90 / night

Quality Suites Stratford

68.2 km (42.4 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Laundry
  • Ironing facilities
  • Fitness centre

Quality Suites Stratford

7.5
562 reviews
From US$ 90 / night
  • Beach access
Circle Hotel Fairfield Circle Hotel Fairfield

Circle Hotel Fairfield

417 Post Road
76.2 km (47.4 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Picnic area/ Tables
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Bar/ Lounge area
  • Outdoor swimming pool
8.1
584 reviews
~ US$174 / night

Circle Hotel Fairfield

76.2 km (47.4 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Picnic area/ Tables
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Bar/ Lounge area
  • Outdoor swimming pool

Circle Hotel Fairfield

8.1
584 reviews
From US$ 174 / night
Hyatt Regency Long Island Hyatt Regency Long Island

Hyatt Regency Long Island

1717 Motor Parkway
75.5 km (46.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Car park
    US$ 12 per day
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool
7.6
460 reviews
~ US$109 / night

Hyatt Regency Long Island

75.5 km (46.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Restaurant
  • Car park
    US$ 12 per day
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Fitness centre
  • Heated swimming pool

Hyatt Regency Long Island

7.6
460 reviews
From US$ 109 / night
Comfort Inn & Suites Meriden East Comfort Inn & Suites Meriden East

Comfort Inn & Suites Meriden East

900 East Main St.
62.7 km (38.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Luggage storage
  • Laundry
  • Fitness centre
7.4
384 reviews
~ US$97 / night

Comfort Inn & Suites Meriden East

62.7 km (38.9 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Free parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Air conditioning
  • Luggage storage
  • Laundry
  • Fitness centre

Comfort Inn & Suites Meriden East

7.4
384 reviews
From US$ 97 / night
The Historic General Stanton Inn The Historic General Stanton Inn

The Historic General Stanton Inn

4115 Old Post Road
68.9 km (42.8 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
  • Free parking
  • VIP check-in/ -out
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Live entertainment
8.4
176 reviews
~ US$197 / night

The Historic General Stanton Inn

68.9 km (42.8 mi) from Shelter Island
  • Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
  • Free parking
  • VIP check-in/ -out
  • Air conditioning
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Live entertainment

The Historic General Stanton Inn

8.4
176 reviews
From US$ 197 / night

Are you in a hurry?

Here is a quick list of Luxury Hotels in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
The Pridwin Hotel

8.5 / 10

(61 Reviews)

 From 334$
Sunset Beach

8.2 / 10

(8 Reviews)

 From 596$
Hilton Mystic

8.5 / 10

(622 Reviews)

 From 119$
Omni New Haven Hotel At Yale

8.1 / 10

(587 Reviews)

 From 73$
Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg

9.1 / 10

(139 Reviews)

 From 173$

Location